The New Mexico Lottery

In this assignment we will discuss one aspect of probability, namely expected value. When lotteries are created, those in charge of determining the payoffs of various ways to win must determine the odds of winning and make the payoffs accordingly. One way to interpret the expected value of a bet is how much money, on average, does somebody win (or lose) in making the bet. The way to calculate the expected value on a simple bet in which you can either win or lose, and winning pays off the same amount no matter how you win, is

expected value = probability of wining × payoff - probability of losing × bet amount

For example, if you flip a coin, bet $1 that the toss will come up heads, and win $1 if it does come up heads, then the expected value is

.5 × $1 - .5 × $1 = 0.

On the other hand, if you play a game in which you have a 1 in 100 chance to win, and you win $50 for a $1 bet, your expected value is

.01 × $50 - .99 × $1 = - $.49.

What this means is that, on average, you will lose 49 cents each time you bet $1. Some games have more than one way to win, and the expected value calculation is slightly more complicated. For example, suppose you bet $1 on a roll of a die, and you win $2 if 1 is rolled, you win $1 if 2 is rolled, and you lose otherwise. Then the expected value is

expected value = (probability of rolling 1) × $2 + (probability of rolling 2) × $1
- (probability of rolling 3, 4,5,6) × $1
= 1/6 × $2 + 1/6 × $1 - 4/6 × $1 = - $1/6

which is about 17¢. This means, on average, you will lose about 17¢ each time you bet $1.

In the Pick 3 game you choose a 3-digit number. You then select one of three possible play types, straight, box, or straight/box. When you win, the odds of winning, and how much you win is given by the following table.

Play Style Example: Prize Odds 1 in:
Your #'s Numbers Drawn 
Straight (exact order) 123 123 $500 1,000
Box (2 like numbers) 112 112, 121, 211 $160 333.33
Box (3 different numbers) 123 123, 132, 213,
231, 312, 321
$80 166.67
Straight/Box (2 like #'s)

Exact or Any Order

112 112 STR $330 333.33
112 121, 211 BOX $80
Straight/Box (3 different #'s)

Exact or Any Order

123 123 STR $290 166.67
123 132, 213
231, 312, 321
BOX $40

Problem 1. Verify the odds given in the table for playing straight or box.

Problem 2. Determine the expected value of a $1 bet if you

  1. play straight,
  2. pick 2 like numbers and play box,
  3. pick 3 different numbers and play box,
  4. pick 2 like numbers and play straight/box,
  5. pick 3 different numbers and play straight/box.

Which of these games, if any has the best expected value for a person playing Pick 3?

In the Powerball game, you choose 5 (white) numbers from 1 to 53 and 1 (red) Powerball number from 1 to 42. Six winning numbers are chosen, one being the winning Powerball number.  For example, here is an example of a set of winning numbers.

   

There are nine ways to win, depending on how many of the white numbers you picked and whether or not you picked the winning Powerball number.

White Balls Red Balls Prize Odds of Winning Ways to Win
5 1 jackpot 1:120,526,770
5 0 $100,000   1:2,939,677
4 1 $5,000 1:502,195
4 0 $100 1:12,249
3 1 $100 1:10,685
3 0 $7 1:261
2 1 $7 1:697
1 1 $4 1:124
0 1 $3 1:70

Problem 3. On the back of a Powerball ticket it says that the overall odds of winning a prize are approximately 1:36. Verify whether or not this is a true statement.

Problem 4. There are 1,120,526,770 total different different Powerball ticket. Of these, how many will win the jackpot, and how many will win $100,000?

Problem 5. If the Lottery Commission wishes to have an expected value of -50¢ per $1 bet, calculate what should be the jackpot paid.

Problem 6. If the amount you win was proportional to the odds of winning, calculate what would be the payoffs for each of the ways to win, given that matching 5 white balls and 0 red balls pays $100,000. Round your answers to the nearest dollar.

The Roadrunner Cash game is similar to the Powerball game. In the Roadrunner Cash game you pick 5 numbers out of 31 possible numbers. You win if your numbers include at least three of the winning numbers.

Problem 7. Many times more likely is it to win the top prize in Roadrunner Cash game than it is to win the jackpot in the Powerball game?

Problem 8. Here is another game of chance: Take opaque plastic cups with 3 inch diameter and place them upside down. Place one ball under one cup. A person gets to lift up one cup; they will win if they lift up the cup covering the ball. Suppose you were to line cups, side by side, from California to Maine, a distance of approximately 3000 miles. What is the odds of a person winning this game?  How many miles of cups would you need to use in order to play a game which had the same odds of winning as somebody has of winning the jackpot in the Powerball game?